Judging by the apparent ages of Carol, Bev, Rich and Bob in this photo, it was probably taken when dad returned from WWII (he was inducted in June of 1942, and honorably discharged in September of 1945)...so it couldn't have been earlier. The question is, WHO is the man on the left?
My first impression was Aunt Katies' Gary, but he wasn't born till '47! Was it his dad? Emails to Gary and Bob (I'm avoiding last names of living persons, ok?) didn't tell me either, but Bob thought it was Uncle Tony....what do YOU think?